Helen Rumbelow
Jean Pierre Garnier discusses medicine in the developing world
I have discovered something that cuts pollution, saves the planet, solves our transport woes, makes you thin, and gives you a warm community glow every time you use it. It is, of course, a car (well, sort of, we’ll get to the fine print later).
And the most amazing thing about this invention is that it could solve our nation’s impasse between militant car-haters, and car-hater haters. It is, as politicians would love to say, a third way. But how do we know this is the future? Because the Government has ignored it.
Let’s start with an old joke. When Labour came to power, John Prescott proclaimed: “I will have failed if in five years time there are not many more people using public transport and far fewer journeys by car. It’s a tall order but I urge you to hold me to it.” Since then, 4.5 million more private cars are on the roads, congestion is rising, and fewer people travel by public transport. Ha ha ha.
I was chortling away too about good ole Two Jags, how we miss him, until I happened on a terrible new thought. I had lived my life according to Mr Prescott’s tenets. While most people cheerfully bought that second little runabout, I had thrown away my car keys. That made me a kind of Prescott disciple. Who was more the fool now, him or me? Here are things I personally blame him for.
1) My lacklustre love life
Although I didn’t need a car to get to work, I quickly discovered it was
crucial for getting any action. Not just for “making out” in, cars were
essential to a romantic mini-break. I once tried to book a weekend to
Liverpool – before discovering that it would take nearly six tedious hours
to return by train. I suddenly got it: the State penalises drivers by
fining, tolling and taxing. But it doesn’t try to make it any easier for you
to go by train. In fact, it wants you to stay at home. Which is what I did,
watching reruns of Brookside on Living TV instead. I was a loser.
2) My miserable home life
Without a car, I was deprived of my basic human right to visit Ikea. I bought
expensive furniture from department stores, just like people did in the
1970s.
3) My low status
On a bike, I was roadkill (cheers, Labour for how little you’ve done to make
that safer!). I had raw welts on my palms from carrying home plastic bags of
onions on the bus. Not only was I a loveless, tasteless loser, I didn’t even
have the enormously large set of keys that men whop out of their pockets to
represent their manhood.
Despite all this, I was not only too cheap to get a car (the AA Motoring Trust estimates a medium-sized car costs £2,600 a year before you put a drop of petrol in), I was too lazy. The amount of administration required for my tiny life already made me want to walk into the sea, I couldn’t bear to add MoTs, insurance, council permits and fines. And that is before you even get to parking. Modern hell must be circling your home in ever-widening loops, as your dinner cools and your baby weeps.
Did I mention the baby? Because, despite the predictions of friends, my partner and I became far too lazy to buy a car after having a child. To everyone who set out yesterday on Black Friday (the worst day of the year on the roads), enduring the entire family’s traffic-induced tantrums, I can only say I’m not jealous. And while I admire women who, solo, and daily, manhandle a buggy in the boot and a baby in the back, I couldn’t do it. I mean those five-point car seat harnesses are fiddly enough when sober, let alone when you’re blind drunk (just kidding!).
So is there some kind of support group for us doomed, carless Prescottians? Turns out there is – it’s called a car club. When one sprung up in our area, we joined immediately: three cars, each parked within a five to ten-minute walk of our flat, bookable – often at very short notice – by text or phone. It cost us no membership fee, no deposit, and the £5 an hour includes petrol and insurance. The “smartcard” for the ignition is the coolest thing in my wallet. I got that astonished feeling when an organisation in Britain works well. We were saved.
You can now have your cake, eat it and not get fat. You can drive a swish VW Golf, save money, the planet, and your waistline (research shows that car club users walk and use other kinds of transport more than before). That’s no mean feat in a society that was dubbed “obesogenic” in a report this week.
Before we get carried away, let’s remember that, like us, not everyone sacrifices a car to join a club. Streetcar, the largest organisation with 20,000 members, says half of their customers give up their own cars, other research suggests it’s only about a third. But, with each car in the club getting 40 users, that’s still a dozen or so cars off the road. Car clubs are not for everyone – but the European example shows that the maximum is probably about one in six car users.
So even though private car clubs are booming, they have a long way to go. The charity Carplus wants to introduce the scheme in the countryside (this sounds nuts, but pilots where people share the “village car” have gone very well). And for either to get where they’re going faster, they need a bit of help.
Help, such as pressurising cities to exclude car clubs from congestion charges (a no-brainer). Or fast-tracking their assigned parking spaces. Or chivvying more local authorities to include car-club provision in planning permission. Or providing a national symbol for car clubs, so that it could be put on road signs. Or, for that matter, allotting space to car-club cars at regional train stations, to encourage city folk to use the train for most of their journey. These recommendations were given to the Department for Transport in a report it commissioned from University College London two years ago. They cost little. They were roundly ignored.
Here’s a totally free initiative for politicians. Just talk about – or even use – the damn things. Car clubs should send the eco-windmills spinning in David Cameron’s head: private enterprise meets fashionable global warrior, and at no dent to his spending plans. He’s never uttered the phrase in public. Gordon Brown could improve his image no end by putting forward a practical, positive solution to our transport nightmare, instead of making life tough for car users and non-car users alike. He’s not interested. This short-sightedness is stupid, and puzzling. Obviously this is a job for the big guns: come back Prezza – all is forgiven.
How to unlock your potential and achieve maximum success with your business

Love Sudoku? Play our brand new interactive game: with added functionality and daily prizes.

Are you irritable when you return from work? Drained of emotion? You could be suffering from boreout
The exclusive satirical podcast that leaves no political hot potato unbuttered
Clarkson went on holiday to Ottawa, hired a dodgy Dodge and 'hosed the Garden of Eden down with 600 gallons of adrenaline'
The best pub gardens, moonlit walks, ice cream, boat rides, festivals, beaches, picnics, cottages in Britain (and a couple in Ireland)

A selection of photographic highlights from the last fortnight as featured in T2

See rugby legends discuss the topics you raised in our summer survey
2003/03
£34,500
North West England
2004/54
£15,000
South West England
2004/54
£48,950
Inside M25
Great car insurance deals online
circa £60k plus bonus
Agrico UK Ltd
Scotland
Up to £34k
Ordnance Survey
Southampton
£
Visit Times Online Appointments for the latest job opportunities working for leading companies.
£30,843 - £33,315
East Sussex County Council
Lewes
Beautiful 4 bedroom, 3 recep property
Guide Price £725,000
Visit Times Online Properties for Homes for Sale or Rent in assoication with PropertyFinder.com
Residential development site with planning permission
£1,500,000
Great deals online
Multi-Centre Holiday 9 Nights
From only £819pp
07/08 Ocean Village Caribbean Cruise Sale with Iglucruise.com
from just £689 pp for 15 nights
Visit Times Online Travel for the lastest Holiday deals UK and Worldwide.
Great deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times.
© Copyright 2007 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Its the life of an average Britisher. I would say stop complaining and get on with it, you have more (even those in poverty in UK) than 80% of the worlds population, stop cribbing. What is 6 hours to Liverpool when compared with 36 hours from Bombay to Calcutta?
Years of poor investment in public transport has caused the rise in use of private vehicles, but that is only a small part of the jigsaw. The big problem is our inability to stop looking for a more comfortable way of living - obviously there will be costs, that is the fine print most miss. Animals cannot wait to gratify hunger, sex....... Humans can, except they don't use this ability bestowed to them.
ASJ, London, UK
According to recent articles in the New Scientist: four times as much CO2 is produced by a person walking four miles (assuming he replaces the energy using with steak) than a modern super-mini produces being driven the same distance. Extrapolate that to multi-occupancy of vehicles and you can see that the way to save the planet is to kill joggers, although in some low-emission way.
So, if car clubs are to be encouraged, we must ensure that their members no longer walk more than car owners. It also shows that, come the revolution, the first against the wall would be those who have taken part in the London Marathon. Car drivers should be way down the list.
Picking on specific sections of the community is not the way to combat CO2 production. You may be doing your 'bit' by car sharing, but it is a very small bit. Take care of the pence and, in reality, only the pence are taken care of. To take care of the pounds you need some form of inclusive plan.
Deek Smith, Brighton, UK
Let's compare the UK with Japan with respect to passenger car ownership implications.
Bottom line up front: In Japan you don’t need a car if you live in a major city.
However, if you insist:
- New and s/h cars far cheaper in Japan than UK. Rule of thumb, 60% of UK prices. Also, better condition, better spec., more reliable service history
- Cheaper petrol (60% of UK), even cheaper diesel
- Cheaper insurance (Japanese MOT includes basic insurance) so no discrimination of youth by insurance companies
- Cheaper servicing/running costs
- SUV/4x4 owners not subject to media-led persecution
- Car ownership has far less influence on social status (ownership not assumed)
- Car ownership unrelated to pulling power. English gentleman is more than sufficient to “ensure you’ll never want for pleasurable company�
- Efficient public transport system greatly reduces dependence on car
- Parking in say Tokyo is less hassle and cheaper than London
Obviously some downside, mostly bureaucratic.
Andrew Milner, Yokohama, Japan